Billy and his first wife, Jess Clare, had three children together, Matthew, Joseph, and Taylor.
He seemed to have a lot of demons and anger issues. He is also survived by his kids Lyric Antonio, William, Michael, and Laila, his wife Renee O'Toole, and four grandchildren.
They seem very defensive and trying to focus on his “legacy” and what a “good man” he was. O’Toole, who referred to himself as a “product of his environment” on the show, was featured in the series with his ex-wife, his daughter, Taylor, and his son, Joseph. Also, I saw posts from Jess Clare telling fans to stop DMing her asking how he died (which is inappropriate). Last week, viewers learned that Dennie’s aunt passed away , and this week, Taylor and Joseph’s dad died. In trying to find information, there were articles stating he died “suddenly”. Billy O'Toole was found deceased in his Staten Island home Jordana Ossad 05/07/2020 The O'Toole clan suffered a major loss during the Families of the Mafia season finale. Billy's father was the much-dreaded mafia man William Sheehan. Billy O’Toole’s death was discussed on Families of the Mafia. He got involved in organized crime at an early age, earning himself the nickname of "Wild Bill."